Tuesday, 18 March 2014

Demographic change in Balochistan and coming Tsunami


Ever since the inception of Pakistan, Balochistan has been the most turbulent province. It has witnessed five major military operations. The ongoing operation which started on 2006 and  was intensified after the demise of Nawab Akbar Bugti an influential tribal chief cum politician has been the deadliest of all operations.

As compared to past, Baloch sarmachars( Baloch guerillas) are now more organized and powerful. They have been successful in not allowing the Gwadar port (bone of contention between Islamabad and Baloch leaders) to be functional. Due to the fear of these insurgents, no entrepreneurs have shown any interest in vast resources of Balochistan because they fear that government will not be able provide security to them against Baloch insurgents.

In most parts of the Balochistan, especially in southern and central Balochistan, writ of the government does not exist. In schools no Pakistani anthem is sung and no Pakistani flag is hoisted.

To counter the Baloch sarmachars, established has resorted to various counter insurgency strategies like kill and dump policy, hiring local people and establishing their own death squads, to abduct people who are ideological proponents of sarmachars. But all these imprudent strategies have not resolved the issue rather it has added oil to the fire. Owing to these insane policies, gulf between Baloch masses and state has widened.

After failing to crush the Baloch insurgency, establishment has now opted for another dangerous strategy that is bring demographic changes in Balochistan and to prove that anti state Balochs are  minority in Balochistan, whereas, pro state Pashtoons are in majority. To achieve this goal, establishment is now importing Pashtoons from neighboring Afghanistan to settle in Balochistan.

As a result of this new strategy, millions of Afghan refugees have settled in Balochistan, especially in the Quetta city. Kharotabad, Pashtoonabad and western bypass are the areas where Afghan refugees are in majority. According to a survey, 50% of Quetta comprised of Afghan refugees. They don’t consider them as refugees, they have Pakistani passport, CNIC and have bought property in Quetta.

This unwise strategy will have grim and grave repercussions not only for Baloch insurgents, but for the Pakistani state as well. The immigrants will never be loyal to Pakistan; they will always remain loyal to their homeland Afghanistan. A visit of Liaqat Bazaar made me confused whether I am in Quetta or Kandahar. The Afghan refugees have put Afghanistan’s flags on the dash board of their cars and they have pasted sticker of Afghanistani flag on the windows of their cars.

A prominent leader of a Nationalist Pashtoon Party openly said that “those who call them refugees they are wrong, this is greater Afghanistan and a Pashtoon who travel from Quetta to Kandahar, he is not a refugee there, similarly a Pashtoon who travel from Kandahar to Quetta, he is not refugee here. Durand line, itself is an illegal border line and we don’t recognize it.” So, instead of countering Baloch insurgency, this import of refugees is reviving Pashtoon nationalism.

As compared to Baloch nationalism, Pashtoon nationalism will be far more dangerous for the state. In the Afghan refugees of Quetta, bulk of the population comprised of Afghan Taliban and in lexicon of Pakistani establishment they are called Good Taliban or Pro Pakistan Taliban and they have no nexus with Bad Taliban or Anti Pakistan Taliban.  But in real, there is no concept of Good or Bad Taliban. They are same, they share the same ideology, they have a same agenda to establish their hegemony in the region and to impose a shariah of their own brand and more importantly they belong to the same ethnic group.

According to the political pundits, after the departure of US, Taliban will easily conquer Kabul and Bad Taliban or TTP will find safe havens in Afghanistan and they will launch their attack in Pakistan from Afghanistan.  There will be a change in the attitude of Good Taliban after US drawdown and they will also become Bad Taliban.  They will join hands with TTP and they will start a Al-Qaeda version of Jihad in Pakistan.

 Unlike Baloch nationalism, Pashtoon nationalism can use the tool of Islam to capture whole Pakistan which means apart from Pashtoon Taliban, Punjabi Taliban, Lashkar e Jhangvi and other Islamic militant all over the world can come to join hands with them  and Pakistan’s chances of defeating these combine forces of Islamic extremists will be nil.

The result will be as that of a Tsunami.

 

 

Sunday, 16 February 2014

Say THANK YOU to a robber






I went to Karachi, last month to give an interview in the US Consulate. After giving my interview, I took an auto rickshaw to go back to my flat. But what happened next was something that I will remember all my life.

It was 8:45 a.m, when I was travelling in Boat Basin, when a boy of young age sitting on the back seat of a motor cycle was saying something to me. I wondered and asked him what happened and then he said give me the bag by showing me a pistol.

I fathom that the boy is a robber and trying to rob me. Although, I am not a typical Karachite, but I have spent substantial amount of time in Karachi during my college life. I was fully aware that street crimes in Karachi are quite common, but what really astound me was the timing and place where this incident took place.

The time was 8;45 which is a peak office hour and  during this time there is lot of traffic on the road due to office going people. It was not late 1 or 2 pm of night, yet the boy was so intrepid that he didn’t care about the rush and broad day light. Secondly, Boat Basin is a part of Clifton which is the  most salubrious area of Karachi and it is considered more impregnable area as compared to areas like lyari, korangi and landhi, but this didnot affect the valour of the juvenile boy. Moreover, our inefficient and feeble police system would have further emboldened him.

  I spoke to him and told him that there is nothing in the bag except my documents and at the same time, i opened the bag and showed him the documents and he replied by saying ‘ok”  and I wave my hand and said  Thank you to him.

The rikshaw driver was amused and chuckled and told me that what is making me laugh is that you said Thank you to a burglar. I told him that there are sundry reasons for me to be thankful to him. My bag contained numerous important documents like my National Identity Card, Visa form, Academic and other supporting documents needed for the visa to be accepted.

If the criminal had snatched the bag, I would have lost all the documents. My trip to America was surely cancelled but my All Pakistan trip was confirmed. As I have given my matriculation from Rawalpindi board, intermediate from Karachi board and graduation from Balochistan University. So, I would have to visit the board offices of these cities and due to Babu culture which is common in most of our government offices, lot of my time would have wasted.

The most convenient way to save time in government offices is to give bribe to the corrupt government servants for doing their duty. I am sure in all three different board offices, I would have been looted again, but that was not enough, there were other places where I would have to go to be looted time and time again like police station and NADRA office. I think everyone knows that our incompetent police do not register an FIR without bribe. Similarly, one cannot get his new NIC from the NADRA office without showing the FIR of the police and more importantly in my city Quetta, NADRA officers are more polite and sympathetic with the illegal afghan refugees as compared to legal citizens. The reason for their hospitality with the illegal immigrants is that for the sake of getting the nationality of Pakistan, afghan refugees pay off the officers and the officers also expect the same thing from legal citizens as well, which means I would have been looted again. So, I had no option other than saying thank you to a criminal for not looting me and saved me from being looted again and again.
 
 


 

 

 

Saturday, 1 February 2014

Bijjar! a fruitful tribal practice



Bijjar! a fruitful tribal practice

Bijjar is a balochi word which means cooperation. We all hear on national television about the drawbacks of tribal system by multiple intellectuals. The primary reason why the intellectuals  rail against the tribal system is that they themselves have minimal knowledge about the tribal system. Their Knowledge about tribal system is restricted merely to snags of this system which encompass things like sardari system, exploitation of local masses by feudals, culture of guns, barriers in way of girls schooling. Unquestionably, tribal system does more harms than goods to a society. Yet, there are heterogenous boons of tribal system and one of them is Bijjar.

Bijjar is a antique component of Baloch culture. According to elders, it is 2500 years old and amazingly it is still prevalent in various parts of Balochistan, especially in Jhalwan and Makran regions. In a tribal set-up, just before the marriage of a couple, kith and kins of Bridegroom ask for Bijjar(help) from their tribesmen, to conduct the marriage ceremony. The tribesmen provide Bijjar in the form of animals like goats, sheep, cows, cash and crops. The relatives of Bridegroom who receives this aid will return it to their tribesmen, when they come to collect their Bijjar. For example, suppose a person has given one goat to his tribesmen, he will get it back, when he will go to collect Bijjar. Similarly, if a person gives one camel, he will get it back on his turn.

Bijjar is a great succour for Bride groom. Even, a common men may collect as many as 200 animals, substantial amount of cash and crops and he has to repay this Bijjar in the form of easy installments. For instance, he has to give one or maximum two goats to a family who asks for Bijjar.

With the assistance of his tribe, the Bridegroom will not feel the weight of expenses of marriage.  Moreover, it will help him in starting his new life. Suppose if a bridegroom get 200 animals in his Bijjar, He may slaughter 25 animals for giving a feast to his guests and may keep rest others animals for his own use. The price of one animal may range from 10000Rs to 100000Rs depending upon the size and genre of the  animal. The worth of 175 animals means 20lac to 30lac Rupees which indeed is a very vast amount. Bijjar rescue the bridegroom in commencing his life after marriage.

One more fine aspect of Bijjar is that it is voluntary one may decline, if he dont desire to give Bijjar. Furthermore, impoverished and people of lower strata are exempted from giving Bijjar.

As compared to dowry, Bijjar is totally opposite. The strain of dowry falls on one family, whereas, Bijjar is a contribution of the entire tribe, which may consist of people ranging from 20 thousand to 50 thousand peoples. Ironically, in urban areas, the onus of imparting dowry is on the shoulder of the family of bride. This is so unjust, a person who is his giving his child to someone to marry, he also has to give dowry besides giving her daughter, whom he has nurtured for 20 years. On the other hand, in tribal setup, parents of bride are exempted from paying dowry. Further, the family of bridegroom is responsible for providing all sorts of help to the parents of bride for conducting the marriage of their daughter.

Dowry is a evil social practice and it is not originally a part of our culture. It is a Hindu Culture, fortunately during the reign of Mughal Emperor Akbar, multitude of evil social practices like satti, ban on remarriage of widows were abolished but this wicked custom of dowry was not obliterated and it is a chief stumbling block in the path of girls marriage. The families of poor girls cannot afford to give huge dowries demanded by boys families.

In my opinion people of cities are very unlucky by not having a beneficial tradition like Bijjar and a sole family has to bear the burden of marriage. Infact, many loose their age long saving for the sake of marriage. By comparing Bijjar with Dowry, even a layman can assume that the custom of Bijjar is far more logical, rationale and honorable than dowry.

There is no doubt that tribal system is outdated and it is impractical in today modern world, but still it contain various handy traits like Bijjar which should not be extinguish as it provide great relief to the couple in their marriage and life after their marriage. The other extraneous things which harms the society like dowry should be eliminated immediately.

 

Thursday, 16 January 2014

Private channels talk shows and ethics of journalism



The year 2002 was a eventful year in the history of electronic media. During the Musharraf long regime of nine years many private channels were launched. Before the emergence of Private channels, there was only one government owned PTV channel which only favored the, who  so reigning government and eventually lost its credibility among the masses. The first popular private channel was GEO and after GEO numerous other private channels also came into existence.

 Undoubtedly, the news coverage of private channels was much better than the PTV. But now there are fathomless private channels in Pakistan and unhealthy competition has developed among the private channels for ratings. To ameliorate, the rating of their channels, the management and employees of private channels can go to any extent. Although,  competition is not a bad thing, but in the rivalry of private channels, the ethics of journalism are being badly transgressed. Indeed, the language used in TV talk shows of all private channels is vulgar and non-journalitic .Even the senior anchorpersons themselves use abusive language and when politicians get embroil in dog fight and use derogatory words against one another, the anchors play the role of silent spectators and never interrupt in the argument of their guests.

The prime reason why the anchors don’t muddle in war of words of representative of political parties is that they just want to make their program sensational and earn more ratings than the host of other channels. Due to the cheap competition, anchorpersons have forgotten their prime responsibility that is to impart knowledge and awareness to the general hoi polloi.

In the program of Express News which is one of the leading Tv channel of the country Talal Bugti, head of Jamhori watan party and Barrister Saif ur Rehaman of (MQM) used abusive language against each other and the host Mr. Kamran Shahid remained mum and permit them to use bazaari words against each other  which is indeed very pathetic. In another instance, Firdous Ashaq Awan abused Kashmala Tariq on live Tv program and the outcome was the same, Javed Chaudhry like his co-journalist, Kamran Shahid didn’t breath a word. In the program of Dr.Shahid Masood, a veteran journalist, Marvi Sarmad (a freelance journalist) and Zaid Hamid ( Defence analyst) used extremely harsh and unethical word against each other and the program like the most of our Tv talk shows ended without a conclusion. It seemed that both these intellectual were brought to the program solely to expose each other and not convey intellectual messages and a senior journalist like Dr. Shahid Masood instead of pacifying them added oil to fire which was appalling. Hassan Nisar, who is considered a think tank in Pakistani media abused Mushaid ullah Khan of PML(N) and a senior politician like Mushaid ullah Khans instead of ignoring Hassan Nisar retaliated with even worse utterance. It is said that when you come across nonsense ignore it with dignity, but tolerance seems like a extinct word in our society.

 The above mentioned journalist like Dr.Shahid Masood, Hassan Nisar and Javed Chaudhry are considered as opinion leader, one who can form, mould and change public opinions. The common people, owing to their limited knowledge can’t form a opinion of their own and they bank on these opinion leaders to form a opinion. But one may wonder what sort of opinion the people will form after watching the talk shows of these opinion leaders.

Fights and pejorative language has become a daily routine in the talk shows. But now, I think enough is enough and this nonsense has to be curbed. The objective of talk shows should be to inform and generate awareness among the masses not to earn ratings. If the anchorpersons don’t have the capacity to impart knowledge to the people than they should only abide the ethics of journalism. Its time for Pemra to inculcate the anchorpersons the ethics of journalism and take stringent measures against those who contravene it.

Tuesday, 3 December 2013

Missing persons case and role of PM

Prior to, the election of 2013, incumbent Prime Minister made lofty claims of resolving the Balochistan issue. Recovery of missing people of Balochistan was in top of his priority list. N-league was the single largest party of Balochistan, as it won 14 seats, but instead of forming its own government in Balochistan, Nawaz Sharif invited a Nationalistic Party to make its government. As a result, Dr.Malik Baloch became the first non-feudal Chief Minister of Balochistan. This step of Nawaz Sharif was a prudent one because Dr.Malik Baloch is a educated, wise and hail from a middle class family. This benevolence of Prime Minsiter of the state generated a ray of hope in the heart of depressed Baloch nation.
 Immediately, after taking the oath as a CM, Mr.Baloch perspicuously said, missing person case is a chief hindrance in straightening out the Balochistan insurgency. He vehemently said, unless or until, missing persons are not brought to the court, the chaotic state of affairs in Balochistan will continue to deteriorate. Unfortunately, the judicious utterance of Mr.Baloch was like crying in the wilderness. The authority concern paid no heed to remarks of the Chief Minister and still bullet riddle mutilated bodies are thrown on the roads on daily basis. Moreover, in the PPP regime. Damage bodies were found in the premises of Balochistan only, but now this malevolent practice has been extended to Karachi as well. CM of Balochistan has candidly admitted that he has failed to settle the issue of missing persons.
 Ironically, the mantle played by Prime Minister in solving this grave matter is far from satisfactory. As a minister of defense, he was summoned by Supreme Court in the case of missing persons. The rejoinder of the leader of the nation was pathetic .Overnight, he resigned from his portfolio and entrusted the responsibility of defense ministry to Khwaja Asif. It seems that it is against the dignity of three time Prime Minister of Pakistan, Head of the largest party of Pakistan, heir apparent of Takht e Lahore , to summon himself in front of Supreme Court. It is said old habit die hard, hitherto, in 1997, he was ordered by then Chief Justice to come to Supreme Court, the result was that the infuriated workers of PMLN attacked the Supreme Court. Mr.Sharif hasn’t learnt anything from his past follies and he is yet not willing to abide the orders of Supreme Court.
 This attitude of Nawaz Sharif is condemnable. He should have gone to the Supreme Court and his presence in Supreme would have enhanced his own reputation and would have further strengthened the democratic system. It would have provided hope to the upright Baloch hoi polloi, who have lost faith from the government of Pakistan. Mr.Sharif should have fully availed this tremendous opportunity and his sincere efforts could have won many hearts and mind not only in Balochistan, but in the entire Country. It was a blessing in disguise for him, but unfortunately he didn’t fathom out it. On the other hand, former President Yousaf Raza Gilani appeared in front of the Supreme Court not once but thrice and was dismissed from his office by the orders of the Court. Despite the bad governance of Mr.Gilani, his deference to the Court should be acclaimed. He might have lost his portfolio, but his dolice conduct has earned for him a feather in his cap. Whereas, reluctance of Nawaz Sharif has exposed his dearth of statesmanship capabilities.
 This act of the honorable Prime Minster will have dire repercussions. Firstly, it will augment the sense of deprivation in the Baloch masses and they will contemplate that Mr.Sharif is only interested in selling their assets like Gwader and Gadani to China and other foreign countries and He is quite indifferent to their grievance. Secondly, it will de motivate people like Dr.Malik Baloch and other liberal Balochs who have opted for parliament rather than mountains to fight for their legitimate rights. Thirdly, it will add salt to the wound of families of missing people who have walked 730 km in harsh weather from Quetta to Karachi to register their protest, but our ease loving leader can’t go to Supreme Court which is only 10 minute drive from his office